Budget Dumpster presents The Fill Logo

How to Hire a Contractor for Home Renovations

Close Up of Construction Tools
By:Liz Kane| Last Updated:03/25/2024
Time to Read: 5 min

Checklist for Hiring a Contractor

Hiring a contractor for home renovations can be overwhelming, especially if this is the first big project you’ve ever taken on. If you’re unsure where to begin, we have a helpful checklist full of tips that will show you how to find a good contractor, including what questions to ask and how you can protect yourself throughout the process.


Hiring a Contractor: A Checklist

Start With Referrals

The first step in finding a good contractor is to start with referrals from family, friends and neighbors. Beyond word-of-mouth recommendations, researching professional organization directories, references and reviews from past clients is essential. The National Association of the Remodeling Industry (NARI) is a great resource for finding reputable remodelers near you. Beyond that, most trustworthy businesses will have review listings you can find with a simple online search of the business name on Google, Yelp or Angie’s List.

Quotation Mark Icon

“If you’re in an area where there are a number of projects going on, take a contractor’s information down, begin your research online and visit their web site. Also, note how many times you’re seeing the contractors’ presence in your community. That’s a fairly decent sign that consumers are satisfied with the work and people are happy to refer them.”
Jody Costello, Contractors From Hell


Ask the Right Questions

Remodeling a home is a time-consuming and costly process. So when it comes to making sure your home is in good hands, you can never ask a contractor too many questions. Once you’ve narrowed down your list of prospects, refer to the points below to make sure you get to the most essential questions to ask before hiring a contractor.

Quotation Mark Icon

“You need to make sure that any contractor you do business with has proven themselves in the past, and will be there if you need them in the future. Don’t just ask the contractor if they are stable, look for tangible proof of longevity and financial stability by asking for the following items: proof of business license, bank letter and insurance certificates, supplier reference letters and customer references.”
Rick Thomas, Thomas Custom Builders, Inc.


Questions to Ask a Contractor

  • How long have they been in business?
  • Are they experienced in the type of work you need done?
  • Are they licensed and insured to work in your area? Can they show proof?
  • Will this project require a permit? If so, ensure the contractor is able to get all necessary permits before starting work.
  • Can they share a list of references?
  • When are they available to start on the job?
  • How do they plan to ensure proper safety precautions during the project?
Contractor's House Plan Layouts
Quotation Mark Icon

“If you ask for references, be aware the references you’re about to receive will be positive. When following up on these references, you should be asking questions like: ‘What would you have done differently in working with [the contractor]?’, ‘What should I be prepared for?’, ‘Is there anything you didn’t like about working with them?’, and then you can go back to the contractor with specific concerns.”
Bryce Jacob, J.S. Brown & Co.


Put Everything in Writing

How do you protect yourself when hiring a contractor? Having a clear and thorough contract is absolutely necessary. The contract should be in writing, signed and dated, and include:

  • Everything you expect from the job, including any promises or guarantees made verbally.
  • Scope of work, including costs.
  • A detailed schedule of all project stages with start/end dates.
  • An established payment schedule.
  • A list of suppliers and subcontractors.
  • Confirmed contact information and a permanent business address.
  • Confirmation of licensing, insurance and all necessary permits.
  • Any consequences for missing deadlines, going over budget or defaulting on agreement.

If any language seems unclear in the contract, speak up and ask questions so nothing in the agreement takes you by surprise.

Planning to renovate your home? Learn the skills you need to tackle any DIY home improvement project!

Tips for Hiring a Contractor

Look for Hidden Fees

While it’s important to have a contract in writing, it’s equally important to understand what’s not included in the contract. Watch out for contractor bids that include “cost plus” and “time and material” pricing models with no cap on maximum budget, as hidden fees can quickly add up. It also helps to be upfront about your home improvement budget to make sure you and the contractor stay on track financially.

Get Multiple Bids

Another valuable tip for hiring a contractor is that the least expensive remodeler isn’t always the best, and a lot of the time, price reflects quality. Review bids from at least three different contractors, as several quotes give you a point of comparison for what’s reasonable to pay for these services in your area.

Quotation Mark Icon

“Homeowners should always look out for contractors who are ready to work and can start immediately – there’s a reason they’re available. If a contractor can’t answer your questions clearly either, that’s one of the things people need to be aware of as well. If something sounds too good to be true, it probably is, and in construction, that’s usually the case.”
Bryce Jacob, J.S. Brown & Co.


Trust Your Instincts

Red flags to watch out for as you begin working with a contractor include:

  • A contractor refusing to provide a written contract.
  • Requests for you to pay in cash or pay the entire cost upfront.
  • The contractor not having a business address.
  • A contractor unable to pull a job permit (they’re likely not registered with the city).
Quotation Mark Icon

“Biggest red flag: If they ask for a large deposit upfront. They’re likely behind on other projects and will use part of your money to fund another one. Illegal, of course, but it is done more often than you think.”
Jody Costello, Contractors From Hell


If you have any doubts or uneasy feelings as you review these contractor hiring tips, proceed with caution or move on altogether. Chances are, your feelings are justified, and you should be working with a contractor you can trust.

Home Improvement Contractor With Miter Saw

Scared of overspending on your next renovation? Create a remodeling budget with our guide!

Tips for Working With a Contractor

Beyond how to hire a contractor, we also have some helpful tips for working with one. First, establish a plan for how you’ll communicate with your contractor, and how often. Second, make sure the workers are comfortable and set ground rules for parking, bathroom use and any other issues that may come up throughout the project.

Quotation Mark Icon

“Whether the project is a complete renovation, a specific room remodeling project, or even new construction, a general contractor has the responsibility of fitting all the pieces and people together to complete the project. If they are not meeting their contractual obligations, discuss the issues with them as quickly as possible, to help alleviate concerns before they become major roadblocks.”
Anita Clark, Warner Robins Homes


Keep an organized folder to track all records, warranties and payment receipts. Schedule a final walk-through to ensure the job is complete and confirm all subcontractors and suppliers have been paid prior to making the final payment. We recommend requesting a receipt marked, “Paid in Full,” for your records when the final payment has been made.

Looking for more how-to tips? Subscribe to our newsletter!